"I don't know but I've never seen Wendy act like this. I'm sorry, but I've got to go after her." You say.
"Yeah, of course, I can't really chase anyone on land." Olivia said, sighing, "I'll try to explain it to the Queen maybe."
You nod and jog off after Wendy. You turned and watch Olivia flop down in the water, sobbing. Yikes, she sure was a neurotic mermaid.
You caught up to Wendy shortly, you were always a little more athletic. She stopped and looked around.
You two had stopped in a glade of some kind. Wendy looked... absolutely amazing. Her hair was a mess and her rather attractive large cock - er Olivia's cock, ah whatever - was once again slowly hardening.
"Did she follow you?" Wendy asked.
"No, she hasn't really got legs right?" You said, "So... what's up? Since when do you steal stuff like that."
"I didn't steal it, as far as I'm concerned, Olivia donated my dick to me." Wendy said, emphasizing that it was now hers, "Seriously, we have to try this thing out. Was it always like this for you?"
You shrugged, "Maybe when I was a teenager. Yours seems a little different."
Wendy walked up to you, still holding the staff, she tugged at your shorts.
"Come on, lets see who's bigger." She said as she pressed her stiff cock against your thigh.
You gulped, she was definitely bigger than you now. It kind of turned you on, but...
"Wendy, I love you but you can't keep that dick AND the staff. You have to let Olivia have at least one back."
Wendy pouted, she turned your shorts down and grabbed your dick and hers in one hand. You gasped, feeling her warm hard meat against yours brought you to full attention. Wendy's uncut cock felt so strange against yours, so soft, it was unlike anything you had ever felt.
"There's no way I'm giving this thing up." She purred.
"Then le-le-lets give her the staff back... oh god..." You whimpered, Wendy's cock and hand were quickly working you to near orgasm.
Wendy stepped back and held her stiff cock in one hand and the staff in the other. She was in that same lusty haze and she just wanted to get off, but she knew you were right... which should she give up