You pick Sarah up and put her on your shoulders. She then takes over and adjuats herself to be snuggly tightened to the point where she doesn't bounce when you walk. It is an oddly pleasant feeling, probably because you know it is your girlfriend doing it. You decide to just continue walking home while chatting with Sarah.
You were not paying to where you were walking and accidentally bumped into something. Returning your attention to the front, you realize you walked right into the Fairy you had just met. She seems mildly annoyed by this, but still greets you again.
"It appears everything is going well so far. But do watch where you are walking."
"Sorry" you apologize. The Fairy smiles however.
"Since we have met again, I can add on a little bonus to your wish, but with a little twist of my own as well. How about it? Wanna try it out for fun?" She offers.
You are not quite sure if she is serious, and if it is a good idea. This could be a prank for bumping into her after all. But before you could answer, Sarah answers for you.
"That sounds like fun!" She says happily.
"Wonderful, then lets make it so that your second highest ranked fetish also is in play. But for the catch, it applies to yourself, as well as certain members of your harem. Not everyone will follow the same fetish though. Some may become furniture, and some may be influenced by fetish #2. Some may even have both."
You are quite startled by this. You knew your #1 fetish, but not the second. While you were lost in an internal panic to realize what your second favorite fetish is, the fairy continued her explination.
"And to keep it simple, whatever it is, it will not negatively effect or impact any current and future relationships, nor your ability to live your life. And may only strengthen the relationships if anything. Here, lets say that you really are into women wearing dresses. Now you will only wear dresses, and Sarah here will not love you any less for it. She may even love you more because of it, but that is up to her. Anyways, have fun with this. I will check up on you after a week or three, just to see how things are going since this is pretty entertaining."
And with that, she disappeared again. Leaving you and Sarah to wonder what is about to happen to you.