"Erika knows more than I do about the whole salve thing. You're right, I should ask her what the hell is going on with it", Cole admitted. He sat with Sam on the bed.
Cole pulled out his phone to get a hold of Erika, who answered almost immediately. He put the phone on speaker for Sam to hear.
"What do you want, idiot? I'm busy", they both heard Erika complain on the phone. There was some noises in the background that he could not identify.
"Listen, there's been... Something's happened", Cole hesitated. "My sister is downstairs breastfeeding babies, and she has multiple pairs of tits. Like, too many for a normal person. Almost like dog teats, in fact... Does that have anything to do with you, Erika?"
"No! It's not my fault! I mean, it was an accident!" Erika protested.
"What have you done with the salve, Erika?" Cole asked more firmly.
"It.. it's not the salve!" Erika replied. "There was another vial also. I don't know what it does, but it accidentally fell and spilled into your pool when Melissa had invited me and the girls at your house. Then everybody's breasts start growing little by little. I didn't do this on purpose I swear!"
"Okay but, that doesn't explain the babie and multiple breasts," Cole sighed again. "Do you think the vial worked like the salve, making them develop sexually? Maybe becoming more like female dogs? Do you think it impregnates people too?"
"I... I think I'm the one who made Melissa pregnant," Erika hesistated. "Something happened at the sleepover, and I had a wet dream and woke up with my penis knotted inside Melissa while she was asleep. But I didn't mean to!"
"That's sick, Erika... Melissa doesn't even know it was you, she thinks it was some kind of dog!" Cole yelled angrily.
"Well, if you've been exposed to the salve and you don't find a way to make the horniness go away, that's kinda what happens... You turn more and more dog-like if you don't mate or masturbate! You must believe me!" Erika begged him.
The harsh reality of their situation was sinking into Cole. "Do you know if it's the same for the vial? Are you friends and my sister going to become more and more like bitches in heat if they don't have sex?"
"I don't know!" Erika cried over the phone. "But I think the more you've been exposed to the salve or vial, the worse it gets. The second time I used it, my penis grew even more, and my body changed a little. More like a boy, and maybe more animalistic. " She was sobbing. "I... I made a mistake. I used it on myself again, and on Emily, and at school today we hid and... and Emily put her doggy penis inside me and, and... I got pregnant. And the penis grows also if it impregnates someone!"
"You what???" Cole shouted, almost losing his mind.
"Stop yelling at me! It's not like Emily wanted this to happen to me... not exactly. I just couldn't help myself in that moment. The problem is, my belly was growing so fast I had to leave school early, or else everybody would have known!"
"What do you mean? How far are you along?" Cole asked in shock.
"I'm... it's over now. I don't know how to say this." Erika paused. "I gave birth to a full litter of puppies, they're sucking on my breasts as we speak. That's why I told you I'm busy! My mom doesn't know, I've hid with them in my bedroom. I can't talk too long over the phone or she'll hear me."
Sam didn't know what to say. She passed her hands over her belly, which was still flat at the moment.
"That's so stupid of you, I can't believe it," Cole said out loud. However a part of him was just terrified, because he had made pretty much the same mistake with his friend. The only difference being that Sam was never exposed to the salve, only the vial, like Melissa. So perhaps the pregnancy would take a few days, enough to think of something.
"Cole... I don't know what I'm going to do. My breasts are huge and hurting, my girl parts are already feeling strange again, I think I'm going to grow a canine penis again soon. And I don't know what happened to my friends, I haven't heard from Piper and Riley since the sleepover. I can't find where I put the salve now, but I think at least you shouldn't let people use your swimming pool at this point."
"About that..." Cole coughed a little. "I went into the pool and so did my friend Sam. And we also played around with my cum and she may have ingested it. And I may have mated with her afterwards. But it's okay since the cum's effect is temporary, right? She's going to turn back into what she was? Right?"
"Well..." Erika pondered for a second. "If you got her pregnant, I don't know how soon that will be. Maybe after she pops." Sam became livid.
Cole shook his head. "I think we'll need to head over to your house tomorrow after school and come up with a plan, Erika. Especially if your friends don't know what's happening to them, things could get out of hands and blow back to us. And what if some scientists came to lock us away or something? I don't want to become a lab rat!
"I don't want either!" Erika sniffled over the phone. "Let's meet up tomorrow at my place, you bring Sam and I bring Emily. We can find a solution."
Cole ended the call, somewhat defeated. It was a hard pill to swallow, but Erika must be right. Sam was probably pregnant, and would go through the same ordeal as Melissa.
"Cole, do you think I should just skip school tomorrow?" Sam asked.
"Well, depends how bad things get for you. Even if you don't look pregnant, how are you going to explain to everyone that you physically turned into a girl overnight? Are you ready to come out as trans?" Cole argued.
"I guess I can try to hide my breasts. Make it look like more progressive changes maybe? But yes it is my wish to come out. I don't want to live as a dude anymore; and this is my chance. I'm sure we can figure something out," Sam mused. She had never felt better in her own body, in spite of the strange circumstances.
"Ok, well. Time to introduce you to my family I suppose," Cole sighed again, thinking of his mom and Melissa downstairs.