"Transform," Susan replied after a slight hesitation. Jennifer stared at her in bewilderment. Susan began scratching the back of her head absent-mindedly. "I have a request," she said shyly.
"You want to turn into a freak?" Jennifer asked.
"No. Well, I don't think I'd be a freak. Actually, if you included as part of the curse that nobody besides the two of us would think I looked unusual, I'd probably have no trouble at all."
Jennifer paused. She looked down at her disgusting tail, udder, and hooves. "Okay, whatever. Just remember that I like being completely human. What do you want done?"
"I've always wondered what it'd be like to have a pony tail," Susan said, sounding more anxious than embarrassed now. "An actual pony tail."
Jennifer was still confused why her friend would actually desire something so strange, but she wasn't about to disappoint. "Okay, Susan. It's your body. Grow a...horse's tail." Susan shot Jennifer an urgent, wide-eyed look. "Oh, and nobody but the two of us will think it's unusual to have it."
Susan smiled now. She could already feel the pulling at the base of her spine. She quickly pulled down her skirt and twisted around to see long, fine brown hairs growing from a lengthening skin-colored core that started just above her pantie line. In less than a minute, Susan had an elegant horse tail that gently tossed about behind her, with silky hair that reached to her knees. "Isn't it gorgeous? It's the same color as my hair, too!"
Jennifer had to admit, Susan looked somehow...elegant with it. But no less ridiculous than she had imagined. "I'm glad you like it, but can we please fix my problem now?"