You watch as the stuff on your foot slowly gives way to... fur? Pink fur?
You stare confused, horrified, and amazed as the latex gives way, but only a thin coating off it. Beneath it, you see that your foot most definitely ISN'T human, as the stuff melts off your big fluffy pink rabbity toes. You muffle a scream as the last of the stuff drips away, revealing that this is most definitely a near-identical (but considerably more realistic, given that it's covered in fur) rabbit foot.
Your immediate thought is that maybe the thing is just a fake, like a big fuzzy slipper, so you reach in. Grabbing the toes you prepare to pull... then stop yourself as you realize that you can feel your hands on the foot. Experimentally, you try to move your middle toe. It wiggles. You do the same with the others, and they react in kind. Slowly but surely, the realization dawns on you that this isn't just some fancy foot apparel, and that this time you won't be getting the thing off short of amputation. You curse yourself for your mistake and try to think of what to do from here.