Now you've a real problem. Before, you might have convinced people that you were just wearing a kinky slipper, but now... well, now it's much too real for that. You can feel every part of it - the warmth of your fur-covered toes, the softness of their rabbity flesh, everything - and the more you try to convince yourself that it isn't real, the more you know that it is.
Now what? What do you do now? What CAN you do? Try to cover it somehow? No doubt someone'll notice the difference in size between your feet. Maybe you could join a freak show? Yeah, because people would sure be interested in seeing "The Amazing Completely Average Man With A Paw But Only On One Foot". Never before has there been such a believable monicker for a sideshow freak. Heck, you might as well just toss yourself in the puddles if you're going to-
You don't even finish your train of thought. Thinking of the puddles made you realize that you still have one chance: mixing the latex with turpentine changed your foot, so maybe doing it again could change it back! It could make things worse, of course, but... oh, who are you kidding! There's no way doing it again could make it worse!
Canister of turpentine in hand and the soft pads at the bottom of your paw hitting the hard pavement, you run back to the streetlight where this all started.