Joey had a sinking feeling in the pit of his stomach. He was shrinking and soon was trapped in a foil wrapper again. He heard the fairy's laughter in his head, and her voice saying, "You didn't think you'd escape the curse for releasing an evil fairy that easily did you, Joey?"
Joey tries to scream, but no lubricated condom was ever designed to do that. Little does he know though that is exactly what he is now. A "Joey Lubricated Condom, Fairy Wish Ltd", with his translucent smiling face wrapped tightly around a turgid penis on the wrapper.
Kenny laughs loudly, having watched Joey vanish, only to have this novelty condom appear in his hand. He smirks evilly as he wanders back over to Barbie. He shows her the condom, which she also finds amusing. Then Joey gets to re-experience getting unwrapped, and slipped over Kenny's hardon. Just like the first time, which Joey had wished had never happened, he is the middle member in a couple of quick fucks.
This time when he is discarded, he does not find himself returning to human form. He lays discarded, full of sperm, on the beach all day. Then when dusk comes, Joey hears that evil fairy laughter again, and he is again wrapped tightly in his special wrapper. The fairy only seems to laugh harder at Joey's mental anguish.
Joey spends the next couple of months as Kenny's favorite condom, helping him to have safe sex with Barbie, and a couple of other ladies. He begins to enjoy being used, at least then he isn't trapped alone with the fairy's laughter. He savours the sights, feelings and sounds of being worn, and used as a sexual toy.