"Help me..."
You look at Alice questioningly. Help her? You can't help but wonder how, exactly, you could help someone (something?) like her, a latex monster that just moments ago seemed ready to force herself on you. She seems to recognize the questioning look in your eyes, as she soon answers before you even need to ask.
"Listen, I used to be a normal girl. I just sort of... stumbled across this place a few weeks ago, and it looked like a fun place so I came here. It was weird... there was no one here... well, at least I thought there was no one. I was about to leave, but then I saw that cat bitch standing around. She looked weird, but it's a carnival so I just assumed it was a costume and didn't see anything wrong with going over to see her when she waved at me. As soon as I got close, she jumped me. She did... things to me. Things I don't want to talk about. Things that left me looking like this.
"The pig was already around before me, but she's different. It's weird... it's like she just had her whole mind erased whenever it happened to her. I don't know why it didn't happen the same to me, but since the change I've tried to act like it did, to act like I wasn't myself anymore just so that she wouldn't figure it out and do more things to me... worse things to me. I didn't want to lose myself the way that pig girl did, so I just stayed quiet.
"But it's different now that you're here! She still thinks that I'm on her side, so I can help you get out! You can find a way out, and you can take me with you! Then we'll both be free! Please, you're my only hope!"
Looking into her pleading eyes, you can barely bring yourself to say anything but "yes". Still, something about this whole situation is fishy...