Tyler took the note back home and found that Taylor and her friends were gone as they had been before. He went up to his room and quickly took up a pen to write a wish. He had been thinking about it on the way back home so without reading the note again he began to write, "I wish that I play football for my school and that I'm the star quarterback. Also Mandy is on the cheerleading squad and is the head cheerleader and my girlfriend. Taylor is always nice to me and would do anything for me. Everyone that Taylor knows will discover that she's a lesbian in two days and will tease her like she teased me for a couple months before moving on to something else. This is my wish. Please make it come true."
Tyler smiled as he looked at the wish he had written. His smile faded however as every word on the note faded until it was a blank piece of paper. He was perplexed as it hadn't done that before. Soon though new words appeared on the note and read, "You were given one wish and one wish only. You tried to cheat by ripping this note up to undo your wish and then making another wish. Now you shall be punished. Your punishment will never be undone even if someone wishes for it to be. Once you've been punished you'll never see this note again."
Tyler stared in horror at the note. It somehow knew that he had made a wish before and now was going to punish him for trying to make a second wish. He swallowed hard as more words appeared on the note spelling out his fate.