Realizing what he has done to Jamie, Mikey decides that he liked Jamie better when she wasn't so attractive. He had heard stories about how irresponsible and sometimes even dangerous teenagers who looked like adults were. He decided to see what setting back the time. He watched a Jamie's shoes became sandals one more, and her toes were painted a baby blue. Her skinny jeans receded until they were shorts, and her pink T-shirt became a sweatshirt again. Her breasts became an AA-Cup again, and her fingernails tuned the same color as her toes. The makeup seemed to disappear, and even her purse seemed slimer. There, Joey thought. Now everything is back to normal.
The rest of the night was uneventful. Joey played with action figures, watched cartoons, and played a board game with Jamie. Soon, it got late and Joey grew tired. Even though Jamie said he could stay up another half hour, he didn't want to. So much had happened that day, and he wanted more than ever to try and forget it all.
That's when Joey realized that his parents would find the empty box. Jamie was in the restroom, so he only had a few minutes to figure out what to do. Quickly he put the watch on his nightstand and put the watch already there away. Now it was a matter of finding what to put in the box. It had to something of his that his parents wouldn't notice is missing...