A while earlier:
While you are taking care of Charles, Captain Scarlett and the girls are being welcomed aboard with much enthusiasm. Before stepping onto the deck, Scarlett whispers, "All ye lasses follow me lead. Do as I do, and wait for me signal."
The others nod, secretly adjusting the weapons hidden beneath their dresses. Due to their form-fitting, lowcut bustiers and lack of pockets, this mostly means thin daggers strapped to their thighs under their skirts. Even pistols had proven too bulky to disguise, though they would be too loud anyway.
Once onboard, Scarlett immediately zeroes in on a tall, handsome sailor with dark hair and a confident demeanor. Sashaying up to him, she smiles and runs her slender hand over the hard muscles of his arm. "Ye look like ye be a capable lover. What say ye, me jolly sailor?"
All around, the other girls likewise approach the crew, sometimes two girls to a man since they outnumber them. This fact goes unnoticed by their quarry. All seems to be going well.
True to their Captain's orders, her crew copies her moves. When Scarlett allows her man to steal a kiss, they do the same. When she deepens the kiss with an embrace of her own, so do they. When she presses herself against the man's chest and lets his hands roam over her sides and chest, it is echoed several times over.
Then, things take an odd turn. Unlike you, Scarlett has never interacted with a man like this, nor have any of the girls. As such, they are all surprised by the overwhelming sensations filling their bodies unlike anything they have ever known. Losing sight of their mission, they give themselves over to these pleasurable feelings, and the sailors happily indulge them.
One by one, or by two for some, the girls are led to various spots on the ship for more private encounters. Needless to say, their daggers are quickly discovered but luckily set aside without suspicion. Assumed to be local "working girls," it makes sense for them to be somewhat armed for self-defense.
Thus, the ship wide after-party proceeds without incident.
Back to the present:
Carefully, you remove Charles' restraints. They are too loose on her thin wrists and ankles. Then, you tuck her into bed and wait for your backup to arrive. Minutes pass into an hour, then two, and you start to get worried. The ball is long over, but nobody has arrived. Has the plan been delayed? You get dressed again, leaving out the corset and other things that require assistance. Then, grabbing the amulet, you slip outside and explore.
At first, the frigate looks empty with no guards in sight. So far, so good. Then, you hear strange noises: thumps, grunts, and soft giggles. Following the sounds, you stumble across the first of your crewmates in the arms of a sailor underneath the staircase. You find another tryst happening behind some barrels.
Figuring out what has occurred, you try to find the Captain. This proves complicated as you find more and more couplings and even a few threesomes scattered all over the place. Needless to say, the whole thing is turning you on.
At last, you search deep in the frigate's galley and find Scarlett intertwined with her lover on top of a pile of empty potato sacks. Both naked, they are too caught up in their activity to notice you. It's kind of surreal seeing the Captain in this state. For now, all signs of the brave pirate are missing, replaced by an amorous redheaded girl lost in utter bliss, moaning and cooing with every thrust.
Biting your lip, you try to decide what to do.