Hearing the name 'Alan', Felicity thinks on it for a moment. She doesn't get any memories, but... It does answer a question of her potential involvement. "So, was this 'Alan'... me?" Then a moment later, "I guess that explains why I don't remember it, and that feeling earlier..."
"But." Lucy continued, unknowingly interrupting Felicity's thoughts. "Don't worry, when I found out, I made sure to punish them. And on the bright side, you don't have to worry about ceasing to exist."
The word 'punishment' only seems to confirm it. "So, they looked at me weird because of what this 'Alan' did...?" She supposed it was understandable for this 'Alan' to be hated, since as Lucy said, what those boys did sounds really creepy. But she wasn't sure if it was fair for them to hate her for it, and they didn't seem to have any reaction to Jennifer, the one who seemingly remembered more.
Speaking of, Felicity wondered why it was that Jennifer remembered, but not her. "Maybe because 'Jeff' lived here?" She reasoned, thinking the stronger connection to the place and Lucy had something to do with it. "I don't know how often 'Alan' was here, but if it wasn't much, then I guess that makes sense..."
A few seconds later, she heard a surprised sound from Jennifer, followed by, "Wait. Did you mess with the transformation?!"
Felicity was so focused on what it meant about her friends, she hadn't even considered that detail. But then Lucy confirmed it. "Yep! I made it permanent! You won't turn back into those creepy boys anytime soon! And the only risk of you and Felicity ceasing to exist is if you want to take that risk yourselves!"
A sense of relief washed over Felicity, hearing those words. "So I'm not at risk of being... erased from existence..." She repeated the information, but couldn't help the fear. "But, which is worse...? Not existing, or... going back to my life, only to find out it didn't exist?"
The sound of a rush of footsteps, and an 'oof' from Lucy caught her attention. "Thank you thank you thank you thank you thank you!" Jennifer almost squeaked out, clearly happy that she wasn't on such a small time limit anymore. This was followed by a sudden silence, Felicity left with time to think.
She couldn't help but go back to the idea of talking to them, trying to sort things out before it gets bad. She hasn't heard the door yet, so she knows they're still there. But... Now that she knew what exactly happened, she also knew how to fix it, which would make things better for everyone.